Yesterday Bloomberg Businessweek published an article titled Mouse Study Suggests Alzheimer’s-Linked Protein Can Migrate Into Brain.
The story is this: researchers took brain matter from mice that had beta amyloid plaque (were genetically modified to have such plaque), injected it into the stomachs of normal mice, and months later found beta amyloid plaque in the brains of the normal mice.
If all you read is the headline of this story, the conclusion is that the beta amyloid from the sick mice got into the bloodstream of the healthy mice and passed through the blood brain barrier to take up residence in the healthy brains.
But if you read to the end of this article, it is suggested that there could be all kinds of reasons the healthy mice ended up with beta amyloid plaque in their brains, such as maybe there is some chemical in the plaque brain sample that passes through the blood brain barrier and causes a chain reaction that produces beta amyloid plaque—which would negate the headline altogether.
Now, watch the news and see how many people with take only the headline of this story and pass it off as scientific fact.
The moral of the story: be careful what you read and how you read it.























I read the study when it came out and had a hard time understanding. Mainly because I remember back in the early 90′s they were studying mice. Twenty years ago.
Marty, I think this statement bothered me the most.(The authors of the study, publishing in the Oct. 22 issue of Science, suggest that amyloid protein may have prion-like qualities. Prions are made primarily of protein and can be transmitted to trigger brain ailments such as lethal Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (“mad cow disease”).
Is it possible it’s all caused by ‘Mad Cow Disease?
Good question, Rose, and the answer is very interesting. Check this out: “In laboratory tests, beta amyloid, the building block of Alzheimer’s “plaques”, did not accumulate if high levels of the prions were present. …high levels of the prions reduced the build-up of beta-amyloid protein…” (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/6254308.stm)
Wild, huh? Just when you think there’s a lead…
Marty, thanks for this interesting post. I wish more bloggers would read the headlines as carefully as you do! I think we do more harm than good when we just reproduce the latest headline or news piece.